Welcome to Scherrer Insurance Agency, providing insurance protection to satisfied customers for over 30 years. Originally founded in 1980 as an American Family Insurance Agency, Scherrer Insurance Agency was incorporated in 2005 after converting to an independent agency. Scherrer Insurance Agency has also been a proud member of the Profesional Insurance Agents of WI, since 2005.

As an independent agency, we offer you more choices by quoting multiple companies, providing you with the best product and pricing to fit your individual insurance needs. Scherrer Insurance Agency represents regional insurance companies, including ACUITY and SECURA, as well as nationally-recognized carriers such as AAA and PROGRESSIVE. Since our top priority is you, we stand out from the many direct insurance writers by providing personalized customer service, rather than providing a number to a customer service rep.

For exceptional service at a competitive price, contact Scherrer Insurance Agency today.


6508 South 27th Street, Oak Creek, WI 53154

Phone (414) 761-9600 Fax (414) 761-9601


         Steve Scherrer, CIC

Home | Our Services | Report a Claim | Biography | Contact

Scherrer Insurance Agency, Inc. 6508 South 27th Street, Oak Creek, WI 53154 Office: (414) 761-9600 Fax: (414) 761-9601 Email:
Member of Couri Insurance Associates